Wouldn’t it be great if you could wave your debt away with a magic wand? Back when I was in my early 20s and dealing with credit card and student loan debt, I became obsessed with what it would feel like to have my debt be here today, gone tomorrow.

Would I make different choices in life? Maybe feel healthier? Possibly even look different? At the very least, I’d have a better credit score.

What if it was really possible to magically get rid of negative influences on your credit score? With certain tactics, such as “pay for delete,” it almost seems as though it is. Before you get too excited, let’s talk about what pay for delete really is – and if it works.

Pay for delete is the act of negotiating with the original creditor or a collection agency to have past-due debt – a major drag on your credit score – removed from your credit report in exchange for paying it off.

Say a debt collector is calling you about a delinquent debt. You would offer to pay the debt if they agree to remove the account from your credit report.

Why would some people want to do this? Collections accounts don’t drop off your credit report after they’re paid, even though the status will change to show that they’ve been paid. In fact, collections accounts remain on your credit report for about seven years (starting from the day your account became delinquent).

Therefore, anyone worried about their credit score might be tempted to send a pay for delete letter. However, this doesn’t mean collectors will comply. In fact, more often than not, your pay for delete request could be denied.

It’s true that collectors reporting to the credit reporting agencies (CRAs) are able to amend their reports. However, a collection agency that amends its reports too often can appear unreliable.

To the CRAs, a collection agency’s unreliability violates the Fair Credit Reporting Act’s (FCRA) requirement of “accuracy and fairness in credit reporting.” This could result in a CRA terminating its relationship with the collection agency.

This is why many collectors aren’t likely to agree to uphold a pay for delete request. It simply wouldn’t be truthful credit reporting, and it would put their relationship with the CRAs at risk.

Keep in mind that pay for delete isn’t a strategy that’s likely to work, but there’s probably no harm in trying. After all, the worse that can happen is you get a “no.” If you want to give it a shot, you can follow a pay for delete letter template.

The main elements of a pay for delete letter template should include:

In order to make sure your letter has been received, you can send your pay for delete letter via certified mail with a request for a return receipt.

It’s important to note that sending a pay for delete letter isn’t the same as disputing a debt. If you’re being contacted by a collection agency about a debt that you don’t actually owe, the Consumer Finance Bureau has a debt dispute letter template you can use.

According to Experian, new credit reporting models might pave the way for more forgiving reporting. That change is now being seen in FICO’s latest model, FICO 9:

If your biggest focus is on rebuilding your credit score now, there are ways to do it other than pay for delete. For example, paying all of your bills on time and decreasing revolving debt (such as credit cards) can go a long way.

It might not be as nice as the thought of erasing all your debt with a magic wand. But the more organic credit building methods are just as empowering because they put you in the driver’s seat.

Pay on time and work to reduce your debt, and you will see positive improvements in your score.